www.rarb.org

JtheLegend · Joined: 16 Jun 2005 Posts: 518

so, normally i don't post complaints about reviews, but i'm a little stunned after reading it. i'll preface this by saying that since i worked on the album i'm obviously a little biased, but i don't really understand the review.
first the disparity & contradictions in the reviews don't really leave me much with a sense of "what went wrong"
second, (and again, i'm biased) i just don't agree with the low scoring of the album, especially by kevin sawyer. anybody else heard the album and wanna comment? i really am at a loss
_________________
j. cannon
Cornell Chordials::2004-2007::
the panic room::producer-engineer::
member of the VocalSource network

PHollens · Joined: 05 Mar 2003 Posts: 436 Location: Eugene, Oregon

Yeah, I'll give you an amen on the low scoring from Kevin... no idea what he was listening to but it sure as heck wasn't that album. Honestly I thought the production on the album was top notch. I'm a little confused what do you listen with Kevin? Do you only listen to your albums from laptop speakers, or video game speakers? Seems like your hearing stuff that I can't even hear in my Studio, or my car.
_________________
Peter Hollens
http://PeterHollens.com

ajg55 · Joined: 31 Jul 2006 Posts: 49 Location: Ithaca, NY

dherriges · Joined: 26 Jul 2005 Posts: 550 Location: San Francisco, CA

I heard a few of the tracks a while ago, as a "test listener" for the mixes. And I've listened to the few sample clips on their web site. I'm not as enthusiastic about this stuff as the above posters, but the "2" score from Kevin seems off the mark to me... it's musically solid if somewhat uninspired, and soloists are generally strong. And the low scores for "Sound / Production" are bizarre; definitely not hearing that. What I do remember from hearing a few full tracks is that I found the arrangements generally annoying, with distracting syllables and lacking the groove / vibe of the originals (Put Your Records On I remember being a particular offender, with a way too rigid and straight beat), and that seems to be borne out by comments in Dave and Joseph's reviews... so that part doesn't surprise me at all.
_________________
Daniel Herriges
Stanford Mixed Company 2004-2007

tat-tong · Joined: 15 Dec 2003 Posts: 335 Location: Singapore

Hmm, in the interest of full disclosure, I worked on Sunday Morning, and was hangin' out in Bill's studio while a couple of the tracks were mixed. The main thing I liked about the album was how well-sung and energetic the tracks were, at least to me. Maybe some other areas could use improving, but I really don't see how an album that's of this technical and musical caliber (definitely at "average", if not better) could get a 2.

Perhaps that's a sign of things to come? That, now that we've conquered most of the technical challenges of creating an in time, in tune, nice-to-listen-to product that can match up to stuff on radio, that reviewers now approach albums simply on the basis of whether the music moves them, technicalities be damned. Kind of like what Rolling Stone does - all Top 40 albums are well produced and technically sound overall, but some of them still get 1 out of 4 stars...

Case in point: the MIT Logs Soundproof review 2 albums back - I vaguely remember one of the reviewers saying that while he HATED the album, he had to give it a 5, because by the rubric, it excelled technically and was well sung and arranged. Would such reviews exist today?

It's an interesting shift in philosophy, if anything. Thoughts?
_________________
Tat Tong
Producer | Engineer | Songwriter | Arranger | Publisher

T2 Productions
Managed by Universal Music (Publishing)
An award-winning member of the VocalSource network.

Chris · Joined: 30 Oct 2002 Posts: 329 Location: Boston, MA

You also may find that newer reviewers may score albums lower, since the general body of recordings that they have heard (only recent ones) are on average of higher caliber than what more veteran reviewers have heard on average (includes older CDs).

Also keep in mind that most CDs that are horrible aren't submitted for RARB review. That also skews scores downward, because reviewers are less likely to hear these CDs than to hear good and great CDs.
_________________
Chris Tess
chris@rarb.org
CASA Board of Directors
Tunes To Teens - http://www.casa.org/ttt

billhare · Posted: Sun Feb 10, 2008 9:59 am Post subject:

ThunderCurl · Joined: 17 Mar 2006 Posts: 85 Location: Silver Spring, MD

Yea, reviews are rough. And so based-off-whatever.
It's been a bit of my own frustration that so many groups have been able to master the "production" end of recording an album, simply by having enough money to pay for perfection, but then that leaves the reviewers to say "so what's left?"

A quote from Dave Trendler's review of Last Call's previous album, Straight Up:"Attention all right wingers — if the idea of a mass of convincingly groaning men (who refer to themselves as "Callboys") makes your skin crawl, avoid the bridge of I Touch Myself… and consider another album. But if you're cool with a little gender haziness and don't mind some cheesy tunes, Straight Up might be worth a listen. After all, the men of Last Call sing with gusto and precision and mix with some masters."

What that means is that there's more to an album than just the production. I might not be a good reviewer because my musical taste doesn't include a lot of hard, driving rock, or Emo music. So if an awesome group put out an album full of my least favorite tunes, I wouldn't like it. And that's my opinion.

Many film reviwers "don't like" lots of amazing movies, just because...well hell, who knows.
So, IMO, it's a combo of the style of background syllables and arrangements that bring the scores down, and the soloists that bring 'em up.

One thing is for sure, though. With a 4, a 3, and a 2, you can't take any of them as a totally accurate appraisal of the album's worth. Hint of Lime doesn't have a number rating in my mind. It's an album by the Class Notes, and a very good showing of who they are. In recorded a cappella, what you hear is what you get; don't trust your eyes.
_________________
Tyler Herman
Cornell U. Last Call ('05-'09)
Rock Beats Paper vocal band- Ithaca, NY ('06-'08)
Quiet Hours- Barbershop Quartet ('08-'09)
"When Freedom is outlawed, only Outlaws will be Free."

jdiamant · Joined: 06 Nov 2002 Posts: 425 Location: Saint James, NY

I, for one, thought Hint of Lime was one of the best albums I'd heard all year. and by "all year," I mean "the three weeks in which every waking moment was spent on CARA nominating."

so take my opinion with a grain of salt, as there was no doubt some aural fatigue involved. but yeah, I was quite surprised by the reviews.
_________________
Joshua S. Diamant
RARB reviewer, 2002-2005
Columbia Nonsequitur, 2000-2004
Bridge 'n' Tunnel, 2006-2008

MCWhitehouse · Joined: 30 Apr 2007 Posts: 28 Location: Gettysburg, PA

ThunderCurl · Joined: 17 Mar 2006 Posts: 85 Location: Silver Spring, MD

Casablanca, don't turn my comments into propaganda. Yes, limeade is the most delicious drink in the world (next to a creamsicle maybe) but that doesn't mean i liked the album because of this. As for the lemonade and salt comments, it just goes to show you that everyone here on RARB has different levels of expertise and experience which contribute heavily to their reviews, making everything biased somehow.

That being said, more people need to drink limeade; it's too fucking good (santa cruz organic limeade, in that cool glass bottle. that's my pref)

P.S. teehee it's simultaneously a jokepost AND a seriouspost!
_________________
Tyler Herman
Cornell U. Last Call ('05-'09)
Rock Beats Paper vocal band- Ithaca, NY ('06-'08)
Quiet Hours- Barbershop Quartet ('08-'09)
"When Freedom is outlawed, only Outlaws will be Free."

DaveGrossman · Posted: Sat Feb 16, 2008 8:53 pm Post subject:

maybe i shouldnt leave my computer unattended. rob dietz is a douche.
love, a stranger
_________________
Dave Grossman
Ithacappella - Assistant Conductor '09-'10, T1/T2/Perc
Henry Fonda & The Falsettos - Founder and Music Director
Rock Beats Paper - The sexy one